SANDWICHES
$11.99
Member of the Tribe
Gaspe Nova, Scallion or Plain Cream Cheese, Served on a Bagel or Bialy
$11.99
$16.49
The Fancy Pants
Fatty Lake Sturgeon, House-Cured Gravlax, Ben’s Cream Cheese, Tomato and Red Onion Served on a Bagel or Bialy
$16.49
$13.99
Peter Shelsky
Gaspe Nova, Sable, Pickled Herring with Cream Sauce & Onion, Scallion Cream Cheese, Served on Bagel or Bialy
$13.99
$13.99
Brooklyn Native
Gaspe Nova, Smoked Whitefish Salad, Pickled Herring, Sour Pickle, Served on Bagel or Bialy
$13.99
$13.49
Brooklyn Transplant
Fatty Kippered Salmon, Apple Horseradish, Cream Cheese, Pickled Herring Salad, Served on Pumpernickel or Rye
$13.49
$13.99
Shelsky’s Pastrami
Pastrami Salmon, Mustard Herring, Riesling Braised Sauerkraut, Served on Pumpernickel or Rye
$13.99
$11.99
Dr. Goldstein Special
Duck Fat-Laced Chopped Liver & Apple Horseradish Sauce, Served Between 2 Schmaltz Fried Potato Latkes
$11.99
$12.99
The Great Gatsby
Pastrami Cured Salmon, Honey Mustard, Horseradish Cream Cheese & Red Onion, Served on Caraway Seeded Rye
$12.99
$15.99
El Vincente
Lake Sturgeon, Plain Cream Cheese, Fresh Jalapenos, & Heirloom Tomato (sour pickle when tomatoes are out of season), Served on Bagel or Bialy
$15.99
$12.49
The Spicy Red, Spicy White or Spicy Blue
Your choice of Baked Salmon Salad, Smoked Whitefish Salad or Smoked Bluefish Salad with Roasted Hazelnuts, Fennel, & Oranges, Cucumber Salad & Sriracha Chili Sauce, Served on Rye or Pumpernickel
$12.49
$9.99
The Holy Mackerel
Smoked Peppered Mackerel, Ben’s Vegetable Cream Cheese & Cucumber Salad Served on a Toasted Bialy
$9.99
$20
The 20 Dollars Smoked Salmon Sandwich
Ruby Red Wild Alaskan Sockeye Salmon, Butter, Red Onion, Served on a Toasted Bialy
$20
$12.49
The Whitefish Club
Door County Whitefish Fillet, Tomato, Onion, Jalapeno, Cilantro and Cream Cheese on a Bagel or Bialy
$12.49
$13.49
The Tribute
Door County Smoked Whitefish Salad, Horseradish Cream Cheese, Wasabi Tobiko, served on a Bagel or Bialy
$13.49
$8.99
The Fishless
Tomato, Pickled Tomato, Cilantro, Jalapeno, Red Onion, Apple Horseradish Sauce and Mayonnaise served on a Bagel or Bialy
$8.99
$15.49
Lewis' Maine Style Lobster Roll
Chilled Maine Lobster Salad with Tarragon Served Traditionally On an Orwasher's Potato Hot Dog Bun, Toasted and Buttered with Ice Burg Lettuce
$15.49
$10.49
Spicy Shrimp Roll
Spicy Shrimp Salad, with Scallions, Kewpie Mayo, Masago, Togarashi, and Sesame Oil Served on a Toasted, Buttered, Orwasher's Onion Pocket with Ice Burg Lettuce
$10.49
$10.49
Crab Roll
Crab Salad made with 100% Real Crab Meat, Bell Peppers, Mayonnaise, and Love, Served on a Toasted Buttered Orwasher's Potato Hot Dog Roll
$10.49
COLD SMOKED AND CURED
Price per 1/4 pound
$10.99
Eastern Gaspe Nova
$10.99
$11.49
Irish Double Cured Organic Salmon
$11.49
$11.74
Mild Scottish Salmon
$11.74
$12.99
David Burke Pastrami Salmon
$12.99
$12.49
House-Cured Gravlax
$12.49
$13.74
Western Wild King Salmon
$13.74
$11.99
Belly Lox
$11.99
$14.99
Sable (Black Cod)
$14.99
HOT SMOKED
Price per 1/4 pound
$16.98
Rhode Island Smoked Blue Fish (Plain or Peppered)
$16.98
$11.99
Fatty Kippered Salmon
$11.99
$11.99
Lean Kippered Salmon
$11.99
$16.49
Fancy Lake Sturgeon
$16.49
$27.96 ea.
Whole Smoked Red Trout
$27.96 ea.
$7.98
Smoked Rhode Island Peppered Mackerel
$7.98
$45 Whole Fish
/
$20 Half Fish
Door County White Fish
$45 Whole Fish
/
$20 Half Fish
$29.95 ea.
Bering Cisco
$29.95 ea.
HERRING
Price per Fillet
$7
/
$2
House Pickled Herring with or without Cream Sauce & Onions
$7
/
$2
$7
/
$2
Roll Mops
$7
/
$2
$10.5
/
$2
Matjes Herring
$10.5
/
$2
$11
/
$2
Kippered Herring
$11
/
$2
$11
/
$2
Schmaltz Herring
$11
/
$2
$7.5
/
$2
House Mustard Herring
$7.5
/
$2
$35.96
/
Lb.
House Pickled Lox
$35.96
/
Lb.
$8.5
/
$2
French Oak-Smoked Herring
$8.5
/
$2
(Seasonal) $6
/
pair | $11
/
$2 pair | $54
/
$10
New Catch Holland Herring
(Seasonal) $6
/
pair | $11
/
$2 pair | $54
/
$10
SALADS AND SPREADS
Price per 1/2 pound
$4.5
Cucumber Salad
$4.5
$5.99
Citrus Roasted Beet Salad
$5.99
$3
Egg Salad
$3
$8.99
Pickled Herring Salad
$8.99
$14.98
Smoked Whitefish Salad
$14.98
$14.98
Baked Salmon Salad
$14.98
$16.98
Smoked Bluefish Salad with Roasted Hazelnuts, Orange, and Fennel
$16.98
$7.99
Chopped Liver
$7.99
$11.98
Spicy Shrimp Salad
$11.98
$19.98
Lobster Salad with Tarragon
$19.98
$4.5
Plain Cream Cheese
$4.5
$5.5
Scallion Cream Cheese
$5.5
$7.99
Lox Cream Cheese
$7.99
$6.99
Ben's All Natural Cream Cheese
$6.99
$5.5
Vegetable Cream Cheese
$5.5
$1
/
each $6
/
quart
GUSS’ Pickles
Half or Full Sour
$1
/
each $6
/
quart
$1 each
Sour Tomatoes
$1 each
$4
/
Lb.
Sauerkraut
$4
/
Lb.
Shelsky’s Brooklyn Bagels & BIALYS
$1.25 each
Plain Bagel
So simply perfect, a plain bagel defies extravagant description.
Egg Bagel
A tad sweeter and ever-so-slightly eggier than a plain bagel!
Everything Bagel
Our everything bagels, dense and chewy Brooklyn bagels topped with onion, garlic, salt, sesame seeds, and poppy seeds, are perfect for the undecided or the person who wants it all in life... and on their bagel.
Garlic Bagel
Crunchy dried garlic meets our gently sweet, chewy bagels contributing to the competing texture that defines Brooklyn bagels!
Onion Bagel
Our onion bagels, dense and chewy Brooklyn bagels, topped with dried onion. One of the classic bagel flavors.
Poppy Seed Bagel
They might get caught between your teeth, but the beautifully nutty flavor of poppy is a perfect marriage to the gently sweet chew of our Brooklyn bagels.
Salt Bagel
If you love salt, then this is the bagel for you. Pretzel salt generously dispersed on the top of a gently sweet, chewy Brooklyn bagel is just, wow! *The truly insane have salty belly lox on a salt bagel!
Sesame Seed Bagel
Toasted sesame seeds on a chewy Brooklyn bagel... What could be better?
Pepper & Salt Bagel
Coated with cracked black pepper and pretzel salt, we jokingly refer to this as a bagel au poivre. It's got a nice peppery bite
Sichuan Pepper Bagel
This is a plain bagel studded with numbing ground Sichuan peppercorns and topped with black sesame seeds
Whole Wheat Bagel
For those who want to pretend they're being healthy!
Whole Wheat Everything Bagel
For those everything bagel lovers who want to pretend they're being healthy!
Pumpernickel Bagel
Rye flour and molasses give these extra chewy bagels their distinctively New York flavor.
Pumpernickel Everything Bagel
A deep brown and complex rye flour bagel with everything topping
Cinnamon Raisin Bagel
Bagel purists scoff at cinnamon raisin bagels, but being around for decades gives them the right to be on our selective menu of "real" bagels (just don't be asking for Asiago/jalapeno or blueberry bagels, ya hear now?
Gluten-Free Plain Bagel
From Philadelphia based The Great Knead, these are the gold standard of gluten-free bagels
Gluten-Free Cinamon Raisin Bagel
From Philadelphia based The Great Knead, these are the gold standard of gluten-free bagels
Gluten-Free Sesame Seed Bagel
From Philadelphia based The Great Knead, these are the gold standard of gluten-free bagels
Bialy
Bialys are the bagel's lighter and more reserved cousin. Unlike bagels, bialys aren't boiled prior to baking. The dough is more similar to a pizza dough, and where a bagel has a hole, a bialy has a divot smeared with onion paste. When sliced open, one side has a hole and one side has the smeared onion. Bialys are best served well-toasted and topped with cream cheese and Eastern Gaspe Nova or any other smoked fish of your liking.
Everything Bialy Roll
Everything bialy rolls are made from the same dough as our classic bialys. They don't have the dimple, are shaped like a small roll, and topped with everything topping.
Garlic Everything Bialy Bun
Bialy dough shaped into a bun and topped with everything topping and an extra kick of garlic
Pastries
All baked in house
$1 each
Mama Ilene’s Coconut Macaroons
$1 each
$14.50 per lb.
Apricot or Raspberry Rugelach
$14.50 per lb.
$14.50 per lb.
Lingonberry & Toasted Spiced Pumpkin Seed Rugelach
$14.50 per lb.
$14.50 per lb.
Clementine & Ginger Rugelach
$14.50 per lb.
$14.50 per lb.
Homemade Chocolate Babka
$14.50 per lb.