SANDWICHES
$11.50
Member of the Tribe
Gaspe Nova, Scallion or Plain Cream Cheese, Served on a Bagel or Bialy
$11.50
$16
The Fancy Pants
Fatty Lake Sturgeon, House-Cured Gravlax, Ben’s Cream Cheese, Tomato and Red Onion Served on a Bagel or Bialy
$16
$13.50
Peter Shelsky
Gaspe Nova, Sable, Pickled Herring with Cream Sauce & Onion, Scallion Cream Cheese, Served on Bagel or Bialy
$13.50
$13.50
Brooklyn Native
Gaspe Nova, Smoked Whitefish Salad, Pickled Herring, Sour Pickle, Served on Bagel or Bialy
$13.50
$13
Brooklyn Transplant
Fatty Kippered Salmon, Apple Horseradish, Cream Cheese, Pickled Herring Salad, Served on Pumpernickel or Rye
$13
$13.25
Shelsky’s Pastrami
Pastrami Salmon, Mustard Herring, Riesling Braised Sauerkraut, Served on Pumpernickel or Rye
$13.25
$11
Dr. Goldstein Special
Duck Fat-Laced Chopped Liver & Apple Horseradish Sauce, Served Between 2 Schmaltz Fried Potato Latkes
$11
$12.50
The Great Gatsby
Pastrami Cured Salmon, Honey Mustard, Horseradish Cream Cheese & Red Onion, Served on Caraway Seeded Rye
$12.50
$15.50
El Vincente
Lake Sturgeon, Plain Cream Cheese, Fresh Jalapenos, & Heirloom Tomato (sour pickle when tomato is out of season), Served on Bagel or Bialy
$15.50
$12
The Spicy Red, Spicy White or Spicy Blue
Your choice of Baked Salmon Salad, Smoked Whitefish Salad or Smoked Bluefish Salad with Roasted Hazelnuts, Fennel, & Oranges, Cucumber Salad & Sriracha Chili Sauce, Served on Rye or Pumpernickel
$12
$9.25
The Holy Mackerel
Smoked Peppered Mackerel, Ben’s Vegetable Cream Cheese & Cucumber Salad Served on a Toasted Bialy
$9.25
$20
The 20 Dollars Smoked Salmon Sandwich
Ruby Red Wild Alaskan Sockeye Salmon, Butter, Red Onion, Served on a Toasted Bialy
$20
$12
The Whitefish Club
Door County Whitefish Fillet, Tomato, Onion, Jalapeno, Cilantro and Cream Cheese on a Bagel or Bialy
$12
$13
The Tribute
Door County Smoked Whitefish Salad, Horseradish Cream Cheese, Wasabi Tobiko, served on a Bagel or Bialy
$13
$8.50
The Fishless
Tomato, Pickled Tomato, Cilantro, Jalapeno, Red Onion, Apple Horseradish Sauce and Mayonnaise served on a Bagel or Bialy
$8.50
$15
Lewis' Maine Style Lobster Roll
Chilled Maine Lobster Salad with Tarragon Served Traditionally On a Orwasher's Potato Hot Dog Bun, Toasted and Buttered with Ice Burg Lettuce
$15
$10
Spicy Shrimp Roll
Spicy Shrimp Salad, with Scallions, Kewpie Mayo, Masago, Togarashi, and Sesame Oil Served on a Toasted, Buttered, Orwasher's Onion Pocket with Ice Burg Lettuce
$10
$10
Crab Roll
Crab Salad made with 100% Real Crab Meat, Bell Peppers, Mayonnaise, and Love, Served on a Toasted Buttered Orwasher's Potato Hot Dog Roll
$10
COLD SMOKED AND CURED
Price per 1/4 pound
$9.99
Eastern Gaspe Nova
$9.99
$10.99
Irish Double Cured Organic Salmon
$10.99
$10.99
Mild Scottish Salmon
$10.99
$12.49
David Burke Pastrami Salmon
$12.49
$11.99
House-Cured Gravlax
$11.99
$12.99
Western Wild King Salmon
$12.99
$9.99
Belly Lox
$9.99
$14.99
Sable (Black Cod)
$14.99
HOT SMOKED
Price per 1/4 pound
$6.49
Rhode Island Smoked Blue Fish (Plain or Peppered)
$6.49
$10.99
Fatty Kippered Salmon
$10.99
$9.99
Lean Kippered Salmon
$9.99
$16.49
Fancy Lake Sturgeon
$16.49
$4.99
Whole Smoked Red Trout
$4.99
$3.99
Smoked Rhode Island Peppered Mackerel
$3.99
$19.96
/
Lb.
Door County White Fish
$19.96
/
Lb.
$23.75
/
Lb.
Lake Superior Cisco
$23.75
/
Lb.
$23.75
/
Lb. (seasonal)
Bering Cisco
$23.75
/
Lb. (seasonal)
HERRING
Price per Fillet
$3.50
House Pickled Herring with or without Cream Sauce & Onions
$3.50
$3.50
Roll Mops
$3.50
$5.50
Matjes Herring
$5.50
$11 per pack
Kippered Herring (Pack of 2 whole fish)
$11 per pack
$5.50
Schmaltz Herring
$5.50
$3.75
House Mustard Herring
$3.75
$35.96
/
Lb.
House Pickled Lox
$35.96
/
Lb.
$4.25
French Oak-Smoked Herring
$4.25
New Catch Holland Herring
(Seasonal)
SALADS AND SPREADS
$6.99
/
Lb.
Cucumber Salad
$6.99
/
Lb.
$9.99
/
Lb.
Citrus Roasted Beet Salad
$9.99
/
Lb.
$9.99
/
Lb.
Egg Salad
$9.99
/
Lb.
$17.99
/
Lb.
Pickled Herring Salad
$17.99
/
Lb.
$22
/
Lb.
Smoked Whitefish Salad
$22
/
Lb.
$22
/
Lb.
Baked Salmon Salad
$22
/
Lb.
$25.97
/
Lb.
Smoked Bluefish Salad with Roasted Hazelnuts, Orange, and Fennel
$25.97
/
Lb.
$13.99
/
Lb.
Chopped Liver
$13.99
/
Lb.
$19.99
/
Lb.
Spicy Shrimp Salad
$19.99
/
Lb.
$35.99
/
Lb.
Lobster Salad with Tarragon
$35.99
/
Lb.
$7.25
/
Lb.
Plain Cream Cheese
$7.25
/
Lb.
$8.25
/
Lb.
Scallion Cream Cheese
$8.25
/
Lb.
$12.25
/
Lb.
Lox Cream Cheese
$12.25
/
Lb.
$11.99
/
Lb.
Ben's All Natural Cream Cheese
$11.99
/
Lb.
$11.99
/
Lb.
Ben's All Natural Vegetable Cream Cheese
$11.99
/
Lb.
$1
/
each $6
/
quart
GUSS’ Pickles
Half or Full Sour
$1
/
each $6
/
quart
$1 each
Sour Tomatoes
$1 each
$4
/
Lb.
Sauerkraut
$4
/
Lb.
Bagels
From Mill Basin Bagel Cafe
$1.25
Assorted Bagels
$1.25
$1.25
Bialys
$1.25
$1.25
Garlic Bialy Roll
$1.25
Pastries
All baked in house
$1 each
Mama Ilene’s Coconut Macaroons
$1 each
$14.50
/
Lb.
Apricot or Raspberry Rugelach
$14.50
/
Lb.
$14.50
/
Lb.
Lingonberry & Toasted Spiced Pumpkin Seed Rugelach
$14.50
/
Lb.
$14.50
/
Lb.
Clementine & Ginger Rugelach
$14.50
/
Lb.
$14.50
/
Lb.
Homemade Chocolate Babka
$14.50
/
Lb.